Tuesday, November 8, 2011

Who really are the descendants of Henry Reeves?

Henry Reeves, Sr. is presumed to be the immigrant and first of this particular Reeves lineage to be found in the American colonies. He was granted 600 acres on Tigner's Creek on the south side of the Rappahannock River in Old Rappahannock County, Virginia (now Essex County), on January 1, 1666. In 1672, he received a land grant of 150 acres in Nansemond County. He doesn't appear to have remained long in Nansemond, returning to Old Rappahannock County where he died on April 6, 1687, naming all of his children in his 1686 will.

By 1753 when Henry's grandson George Reeves (son of Henry Reeves, Jr.) died, he named various nieces and nephews as legatees. After this 1753 will, there are few probate records for this family to aide in clearly identifying future generations. Four sons of Thomas Reeves, Sr. were mentioned in George's will, Henry, George, Thomas Jr. and John. Of those four, further records can only be found of Thomas, Jr. and John.

Capt. John Smith's Map including the Rappahannock RiverGeorge Reeves of Grayson County, Virginia is noted in numerous family trees and websites as being the son of Thomas Reeves of Spotsylvania County, son of Henry Reeves, Jr. Since the DNA of several descendants of George Reeves is a match to members of my own Reeves’ family, I have been searching for some documentation to either prove or disprove these assertions. Three descendants of George Reeves have been placed in Group 6 of the Reeves’ DNA Project along with three descendants of William Reeves of Wake County, North Carolina.

Conversely, a participant in DNA Group 9 which is a completely different lineage, has a pedigree that extends to John Reeves, born circa 1730 in Spotsylvania County, the son of Thomas Reeves, Sr. If the research in this pedigree is accurate which it appears to be, DNA Group 9 is the lineage that descends from Henry Reeves of Essex County.

The three descendants of George Reeves of Grayson County in DNA Group 6 match 34 to 36 markers out of 37 with descendants of William Reeves of Wake County, North Carolina. It is worthy of note that there was a George Reeves living in the Orange/Johnston County area (became Wake in 1771) in close proximity to William Reeves and associated with him in various deeds. Also living in this area and associated with William and George Reeves was Richard Burton, father-in-law of George.

Both Richard Burton and George Reeves sold their property in Johnston County around 1765 which coincides with their appearance in the New River area in 1767. Additionally, a Johnston County court order of July 15, 1766 records Timothy Shaw replacing George Reeves as overseer of the road which was probably the result of George Reeves’ removal from the area.

When documents with signatures by George Reeves of Grayson County or his sons can be found, their surnames are written "Reves" just as William Reeves of Wake County and his sons. This was not the case in the Henry Reeves family.

John Reeves of the Group 9 lineage was named as a legatee in the 1753 will of his uncle George Reeves in Spotsylvania County, Virginia. He is recorded in the land records of Augusta County along with his brother, Thomas Reeves, Jr. from the 1760’s to the 1780’s. After the formation of Rockingham County, he is on the tax lists there in 1792 and his death in 1799 was recorded in Augusta County.

Although George Reeves also named a nephew George, son of his brother Thomas Reeves, in his will, nothing can be found to support a conclusion that George Reeves of Grayson County is that person. From the available extant records and the results of DNA testing, George Reeves of Grayson County is of another Reeves' lineage, not that of Henry Reeves of Essex County.

2 comments:

  1. I would like to add group #14 to the list of possible true descendants of Henry Reeves of Essex County VA. The two members of group 14 both descend from George Reeves Jr of Grayson County. One of the group 14 members descends through George Reeves, Jr. son, Rev Enoch Reeves. The other member descends from a Reeves branch that descended through Nebraska.
    Any thoughts on how these lines relate would be appreciated. George Reeves, Jr. and his descendants have the additional mystery of the murder of George by William Toliver in 1811.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. David,

      I'm aware of DNA Group 14 and the fact that their DNA doesn't match that of the other descendants of George Reeves of Grayson County. I can't think of any reasonable explanation other than possibly an adoption. Of the other three participants descending from George Reeves in the Reeves DNA Project, two descend from Jesse and one from John.

      These two individuals also don't match Group 9 where a participant has a valid paper trail to Thomas Reeves of Spotsylvania and a descendant of Henry Reeves of Essex.

      To make the whole matter even more mystifying, I can't see how George Reeves of Nebraska could be the son of George Reeves, Jr. There may be something I'm not aware of, but the George T. Reeves, born about 1811 who remained in Ashe County is believed to be the son of George, Jr. He was also 10-15 years younger than the George Reeves who married Elizabeth Doughton and migrated to Nebraska. I was convinced that George Reeves of Nebraska was the son of Jesse Reeves and his first wife Elizabeth Terrell who would have been of the right age and left the Grayson/Ashe area sometime in the 1830's. If he was the son of Jesse, then the DNA issue is even more puzzling.

      Are you one of these participants? I am curious as to whether their DNA matches any other surname groups.

      Thanks for your comments.

      Delete